FoodPlacee Passport United States · New York · 60232
Verified Carter's Creamery
Cazenovia, New York, USA
Rating★ 4.5 / 5
CategoryIce Cream Shop
Food Place Passport
Carter's Creamery in New York
Discover Carter's Creamery in Cazenovia, NY. Enjoy top-rated ice cream, popular sundaes, wheelchair accessibility, and friendly onsite service.
3 Sullivan St, Cazenovia, NY 13035, United States
Overview
About This Food Place
Carter's Creamery is a beloved ice cream shop located in Cazenovia, NY. Known for its creamy texture and wide variety of flavors, this charming spot offers a warm small-town vibe paired with friendly and attentive staff. The shop is popular among locals and visitors alike for its thoughtfully crafted sundaes and specialty treats.
Visitors can savor delicious offerings such as the Hot Fudge Sundae and the Peanut Butter Chocolate, making it a perfect destination for those seeking a casual dessert experience. Situated conveniently on Sullivan Street, Carter's Creamery features onsite seating, including outdoor tables that complement its welcoming atmosphere.
Gallery
Photos from Carter's Creamery
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Local favorites
Why People Come Here
Carter's Creamery is celebrated for its delicious ice cream creations and welcoming atmosphere in the heart of Cazenovia.
Highly Rated Treats
With a 4.5-star rating from 77 reviews, the rich and creamy textures impress visitors every time.
Popular Signature Dishes
Favorites like the Hot Fudge Sundae and Peanut Butter Chocolate offer indulgent satisfaction.
Friendly Onsite Service
The attentive staff provides prompt and cordial service, enhancing every visit.
Convenient Location & Parking
Situated at 3 Sullivan St, the shop offers wheelchair accessible entrances and parking for easy access.
Inviting Atmosphere
Outside seating allows guests to enjoy their treats alongside a charming small-town vibe.
Experience
When & How to Enjoy This Place
Perfect for a sweet treat anytime, Carter’s Creamery offers a comforting experience that suits a variety of occasions and tastes.
Enjoy a velvety ice cream treat in a relaxed setting, whether stopping in after outdoor adventures or winding down the day with family and friends. The shop’s diverse menu and generous portions cater well to both sundaes and shakes enthusiasts. — FoodPlacee editorial note
Family-Friendly Outing
Bring the kids or meet up with loved ones to share large portions and classic favorites like the Peanut Butter Chocolate sundae in a welcoming, small-town atmosphere.
Weekend Treat
Stop by on a Saturday or Sunday evening to enjoy super friendly service and a variety of flavors that make a perfect weekend indulgence.
Outdoor Seating Delight
Take advantage of onsite tables outside and savor ice cream shakes or sundaes while soaking up the summer air or relaxing in the neighborhood ambiance.
Spur-of-the-Moment Stop
A quick walk-up window visit makes for an easy late-night or after-hiking dessert stop offering creamy, well-balanced flavors.
Popular sundaes Family-friendly Weekend visits Outdoor seating Late-night cravings Accessible parking Casual atmosphere
Guest sentiment
What People Feel
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
JG
Jeffrey Grohman 3 week ago
"We went on a spur of the moment late one Saturday night. minutes before they were due to close. It wasn't a big croud, just two or three other groups. We got our ice cream (a coffee sugar cone for me). It was creamy, not too frozen but not too melty either. I'd say just right. It had that velvety texture and sweetness that made it wonderful. Now I'm not saying that this is the best ice cream I've ever had, but I am saying it was damn good. As to price, well I think all ice cream is over priced. But , the prices are no different from other quality ice cream shops. Finally, you buy your ice cream out of a window on the street. Works for me in hot dry weather."
PRE
Procopio Real Estate 3 week ago
"When in Cazenovia carter's creamery is a must stop for us. They make the best chocolate milkshakes. Service is always prompt and the staff is friendly. Prices are very reasonable and you can enjoy your ice-cream at their outside tables."
JA
Judson Ames 1 month ago
"Great service average prices. Had the Nelson Swamp. I was skeptical of the bacon bits but it was fantastic! A great walk up ice cream window. Good small town feel."
SK
Stuart Kyle 1 month ago
"Great, friendly service. Reasonable prices. The ice cream was good!"
HM
Hannah MacIntosh 2 month ago
"This shop does not mess around with it's sundaes! I ordered the Funky Monkey and it was delicious. The portion size was shareable and the sundae was immaculately designed. There are a wide variety of flavors, sizes, cones and toppings. It is a can't miss spot for the summer (or anytime)!"
HM
Hugh McCurdy 2 month ago
"Good but not great. Would go again. I had the hot fudge sundae. Good but a less generous serving vs my experience at other similar ice cream stands. I ended up having some of my wife's shake which was good but I've had better from similar shops."
JE
John Elmer 3 month ago
"Great neighborhood ice cream place. Has lots of flavors and good size portions. Some outside seating"
RP
Regina Petrera-chiarizia 3 month ago
"Stopped here after hiking the local water falls and it was the perfect way to end the day. Great taste and I highly recommend the ice cream nachos!"
Visit info
When to Visit
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
Today Updating...
Best time to visit
Plan your visit for a delightful ice cream experience with minimal wait and great ambiance.
Weekend evenings offer a relaxed atmosphere Late-night visits on Saturdays are ideal Early evenings during weekdays tend to be less busy
On the map
Where This Food Place Lives
Find your way to Carter's Creamery in New York .
Address 3 Sullivan St, Cazenovia, NY 13035, United States
Phone +1 315-815-4300
Area New York
Call Address copied ✓
Questions answered
Food Place Questions
Find answers to common questions about Carter's Creamery, the beloved ice cream shop in Cazenovia, NY.
Some favorites include the Hot Fudge Sundae and the Peanut Butter Chocolate. The menu offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors, sizes, cones, and toppings to satisfy different tastes.
Yes, the shop features a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, ensuring convenience for all customers.
Onsite services are available, allowing customers to enjoy ice cream in a welcoming setting that includes outdoor seating options.
It’s located at 3 Sullivan St, Cazenovia, NY 13035, United States. For inquiries, call +1 315-815-4300.
With a 4.5-star rating from 77 reviews, Carter's Creamery is praised for friendly service, good portion sizes, and tasty ice cream, though some find prices slightly high.
Menu items and availability can change, so checking directly with the shop is recommended to discover current specials and seasonal flavors.
Nearby brands
Related food places near Carter's Creamery
Other casual restaurants and brands diners often visit in New York.
For owners
Own or manage this food place?
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.